Wednesday, 23 April 2014

What Indians Wore In The Trenches


We've had fantastic feedback from many of you on our new trailer (above) for our forthcoming film "Indians in the Trenches".  The film depicts the real life experiences of those who fought during World War One - told by amateur actors narrating the real letters sent betweem 1914 - 18.

Telling the story through the actual words written by those who experienced the war was important for us, as it meant we could harness the truth of their emotions and sentiments.  The letters tell us a lot about the state of mind of the soldiers - from those who missed their family and India, to those who were proud of doing their part in the war.  There were also those who saw horrific things and wanted the madness to end.  In depicting the film we wanted it to be as real as possible and the letters enabled us to achieve that in ways that any other type of script could not.

To ensure we did the story justice, the authenticity of the period uniforms was a crucial element of our depiction.  We were pleased to have with us Edwin Field (above) from the Die Hards Re-enactment group who not only curated the look of the soldiers but was a font of knowledge for us to understand more about the kit the soldiers had.

Prior to the shoot, I'd spent quite a lot of time researching what Indians wore in the trenches, but seeing for myself the various items of clothing was important - and I want to share that with you with hopes that you'll be inspired to find out more or utilise this post as a resource.

Indians arrived in France in Khaki Drill.  This is because the soldiers wore KD in India and commanders had thought the Indians would be deployed to Egypt.  But Indian Expeditionary Force A which set out in August 1914 had a different purpose, to help reinforce the defence on the western front and stop the Germans reaching the Cinque ports.

And so Indians arrived wearing this cotton khaki in France, a light dress which was unsuitable for the cold conditions of a European winter.  Their kit contained a great coat, which was the only warm item of clothing they had.

The Indians fought in this kit in cold conditions - but despite being badly equipped it did not stop them from some daring feats of bravery in the trenches and in fighting the Germans.  In 1914-15 alone 53 Indian Order of Merit and 6 Military Cross medals were rewarded to Sikhs in particular (research courtesy of Narindar Dhesi's "Sikh Soldier").

By mid-1915, the shirts were replaced with thicker jackets, as seen on the left modeled by Joban Singh from the "Indians in the Trenches" film,as photographed by the Wedshot team.  But this mattered to little to many of the soldiers as Indian infantry units were removed from the western front and redeployed in arena's including Mesopotamia.

By the end of 1915, the cavalry units which remained in France were issued woolen clothes for the harsh winters.  Cavalrymen would stay and fight until the end of the conflict.

There is also a difference in the kit of Native Indian officers and other ranks, with the former being issued Sam Browne equipment and tending to have larger turbans.  Harmeet Singh Bharaj, on the left, is depicting a Risaldar in July 1917 so is seen with a lighter khaki jacket with 1903 pattern leather belt pouches and a handgun.

Understanding the various uniform changes makes a difference when looking at images of Indians in general from the First World War for it enables researchers to see which year they are from - and understand how those fighting were equipped.

We certainly relied on such images in our filmmaking, but learnt a lot from Edwin about spotting the difference, such as the thinner shirts having 2 pockets and the thicker jackets 4.  Knowing that the Indians deployed to the western front began the conflict ill-equipped is a well known fact, but as better kit was supplied to them so too was the realisation that they were there for longer than they might have expected.

The Sikhs were the most visible of the soldiers deployed in every arena of the war.  While orders went out for helmets to be worn by Indian soldiers to protect from shrapnel, it was recognised at once that this would not work for the Sikhs whose turban remains a fundamental part of their identity.  Sikhs wore their turbans in conflict, although images of the conflict show non-Sikh cavalrymen wearing turbans in apparent combat, for the Sikhs it was a strict adherence and a sign of the pride in their faith.

Despite some images of the era showing otherwise, regimental cap badges too were worn on the turban in the trenches too.  This came as a surprise to us, as in combat having a metallic item which reflects light and shines would give away the position of a soldier.  I can only think that the while Sikhs maintained the dress code and chakkar on the turban with pride and in defiance of the enemy, it would be sensible to assume these were removed for night time or more covert operations.

Finally, many Indian soldiers who were injured in France and Flanders were brought over to England to recover at Brighton Pavillion.  The black and white photos of the time hide it well, but the period dress of a hospital patient is very surprising too: a white shirt, red tie and blue jacket and trousers was worn by them. Azadbir Singh Atwal on the left demonstrates this, with a rather worn out turban in this scene.

In all, the uniforms of the period evolved somewhat as the needs of the Indian soldiers became apparent.

It was an amazing experience working with young volunteers who had hardly any acting experience - but who felt the power of the letters sent from the trenches.  In coaching the actors and providing the motivation for their words it began clear to me what the overriding feelings and sentiments were of those who fought.

In our next post, I'll go into more details about the psyche of the Indians in the trenches - and why it was belief in their martial traditions that kept many Sikhs in high spirits at the hardest of times.

**Visit www.sikhsatwar.info for our online films **

Tuesday, 15 April 2014

Indians In The Trenches: The Trailer



Dot Hyphen Productions are pleased to present the trailer for the forthcoming film "Indians In The Trenches".

Coming soon this summer to www.sikhsatwar.info

Directed by Jay Singh-Sohal
Executive Producer Juggy Rehnsi / Wedshot Ltd.


Thursday, 10 April 2014

Indians in the Trenches: The Shoot

I'm writing this after a long and productive day of shooting for one of our new films "Indians in the Trenches".

To say we achieved a lot during a busy day would be an understatement, as we balanced shooting with amateur and professional actors alongside a BBC crew who had come to document our work.

As a Dot Hyphen Production we once again turned to our trusted professional close friend Juggy Rehnsi for his creative direction - utilising his light studio space to create sets that matched the action being depicted.  The set up at Wedshot enabled us to maximise our work - making best use of light and technical equipment to do justice to the story.

But we could not have achieved what we have, as evidence in these fantastic images, without the input of our historian and WW1 consultant Edwin Field from the Diehards.  From matching the right kit to the right individual according to their period in the war to ensuring accuracy in portrayal in every element of our shoot, it was fantastic to have Edwin with us on the day.


My thanks to all our actors who volunteered to be a part of this new film: Diljohn Sidhu, Harmeet Singh Bharaj, Pavandeep Singh Sandhu (top left), Azadbir Singh Atwal (centre right), Jobanjeet Singh (bottom left), Gurdev Singh (bottom right), Endip Singh Rai.

We have enjoyed working with these guys, a thoroughly nice bunch of lads.  While we take a lot of pride in inspiring people through the deeds of our ancestors - we also get a lot of satisfaction from developing young talent, and so I hope we can help develop their careers to.

Finally, we look forward to sharing our hard work and efforts with you all in due course.  "Indians in the Trenches" is slated for release in September when we will be bringing you a new web resource at www.sikhsatwar.info

Friday, 4 April 2014

The Numbers Game

Establishing facts and stats about the Indians who fought during the Great War is crucial to our understanding of who they were and their achievements.

So it was with dismay that I came across a book recently where the numbers of Sikhs represented in the Great War was over-inflated with the inclusion of those non-Sikhs who's name was "Singh".  

As mentioned in a previous post, the class based system the British employed meant that many ethnic groups in India served in various regiments, some such as the Rajputs and Dogra's had the surname Singh but were not Sikh.

Including these numbers does not paint an accurate portrait of the Indians who fought - and certainly when it comes to their achievements incorrectly listing medal winners as Sikh when they are not doesn't help our understanding of each communities contribution neither.  

A case in point is on VC winners, Risaldar Badlu Singh who showed remarkable bravery and courage in Egypt was not Sikh but a Hindu Jatt.  Lance Dafadar Gobind Singh who won a VC in France was not Sikh but a Rajput.

I've been trawling through medal winners in order to try and establish an accurate number of winners of VCs, MCs and IOM's etc to highlight the heroics of the Sikhs during the Great War - who achieved a lot despite their small numbers in the field and as 2% of the Indian population at the time.

Trawling through thousands of pages of names and regiments where it is unclear of the race of the soldier is an extremely difficult task, and one where more research needs to take place.  So I am thankful for the hard work and efforts of one writer in particular in establishing an accurate picture of the heroic Sikh contribution.


Narindar Singh Dhesi (above) has written countless books on the subject of the "Sikh Soldier" and having recently met and spoken to him I am thankful that he has established the facts surrouding the Sikh contribution - which has been extremely helpful in my own research and filmmaking.

It might seem a thankless task to trawl through such data - but Narindar's work has inspired me to seek the truth of the war.  I hope showing this through our upcoming films will inspire other young people in particular to delve into our history too.

Narindar's books are available here.

Wednesday, 26 March 2014

Turbans of the British Indian Army

Recent posts on popular social media groups such as "Great Sikh Battles" got me thinking that a blog about writing this post about the Turbans worn in the British Indian Army.

As the author of  "Turbanology: Guide to Sikh Identity"  it irks me that when talking about the Sikh contribution - researchers and writers often make the mistake of counting anyone who is a 'Singh' or has a turban as a Sikh, thus exaggerating the numbers of those who served.  This doesn't help our understanding of the conflict nor the sacrifices of our ancestors.

The turban is fundamentally a part of Sikh identity - it encases uncut hair on the head, and for men is complimented by an unshorn beard.  The hair is a sacred symbol, one of the 5 K's and which all Sikhs keep in accordance with the will of God.

But the turban is not a solely Sikh symbol - it is associated with the east and shared with many other faiths and cultures across Asia.  This is best seen in India where the turban is worn by many non-Sikhs.

Turning to the period of Empire, Sikh soldiers were distinguishable by their turbans and uncut beards.  But all British Indian regiments embraced the turban as the primary ceremonial form of regimental headdress worn by all ranks regardless of faith.  Even British officers donned the turban.

During conflicts such as the Great War, many Indians would switch their turbans for helmets for combat - but the Sikhs were afforded the respect and dignity of always maintaining their dastaar and thus their faith and identity was represented even in battle.

But when we see images of these conflicts, many are confused by who the turban-wearing Indians are, so this blog is designed to shed light on this - and we can do so by looking at the style of turbans in question.

So what were there different turban styles.  Here are some examples:


L - R:  Sikh with 24th Punjabi / (Hindu) Jatt with 12th Pioneers / Punjabi Muslim

 
L - R:   Rajputa Muslim with 128th Pioneers /  Afridi with 24th Punjabis

British Indian regiments during the time of Empire were organised on a class-based system.  While some were solely Sikh, Rajput or Brahmin regiments - others had a mix of squadrons or companies of different races.

For example - the 36th Sikhs, famed for it's defence of Samana and heroics at Saragahi, was a regiment based wholly of Sikhs.  While the 27th Punjabis, who achieved battle honours in China, Afghanistan and Burma; was a mixture of Sikh, Hindu Dogra, Punjabi Muslim and Pathan companies.

The classes that made up British Indian regiments in 1914 were:
Sikh, (Hindu) Dogra, (Hindu) Jatt, Punjabi Hindu, Brahmin, Punjabi Muslim, Rajputana Muslim, Dekhani Muslim, Pathan, Hazaras, Afridi, Orakzais, Khattaks

Sikhs were further organised into: Jatt, non-Jatt, Lobana, Mazbi & Ramdasia squadrons or companies.  This was not because the British embraced the caste system but rather because of the prowess in various arms of the classes.  We will leave further discussion of this to a future post.

While turbans are not the same in how they are tied, we can certainly see similarities in how tthe various races tied their turbans which lends us to be able to analyse photos and say with some credibility who they belong to.

If you have any real images of British Indians in turbans please do share on this post thread, and let's see if we can spot which race the soldiers belong to.

Wednesday, 19 March 2014

New "Sikhs At War" Logo

We tasked our favourite artist Jag Lall to create a new logo for the "Sikhs At War" project.

We went through a long procedure to iron out the best motif - debating what we wanted to depict in order to show the shared British-Sikh history and inspire others to feel proud about their connection and service during the Great War.

Below are some of the design concepts Jag came up with, which we creatively discussed:


The common theme was the chakkar / silver circle.  This denotes the oneness with God that Sikhs believe in - reflected within the kara or iron bracelet that forms one of the 5 K's which all Sikhs wear.

The Sikh soldier too is represented - in memory of the countless tens of thousands who fought for freedom and against tyranny in every arena of the Great War.  The soldiers turban is large, this was the only defence Sikhs had in war and they'd often find bullets within them!  The beard appears trimmed but isn't - Sikhs did not cut their hair even in combat; but the beard was kept tied up to stop it jamming in the rifle.

We debated about whether to keep the Union Jack flag and Nishaan Sahib - but in our final choice we were won over by simplicity as we didn't feel the need to make this extroversial gesture.

Our final choice for our logo is the final one above - image 6.

We feel this pays tribute to the memory of Sikhs during the Great War - please do comment and add your thoughts.

Tuesday, 18 March 2014

Skinner's Horse

I recently made contact with Skinner's Horse, a riding group that recreate the heroics of the famous British Indian regiment.


The group are looking for Sikhs/Indians who can ride to join their organisation - in order to better reflect the make up of the regiment.

If you're interested - click on the links above and get involved!

It's worth noting that Skinner's Horse was one of many cavalry regiments made up of class based squadrons - with Sikhs serving alongside Rajputs, Muslim Rajput and Hindu Jatts.

All saw action during the Great War, and received great recognition in France and Flanders before being moved to Mesopotamia.

Please do comment on this thread about the group - and any stories or pictures you may have.

Thursday, 13 March 2014

Abusing intellectual property is not on!

*** UPDATE on 19/3/14 ***

Further to the below post, I've now spoken to the founder/manager of Akaal Channel (AS Kooner).  We had a good measured conversation - and what struck me was that he wasn't interested in £ but moving forward as a community and with good relations intact.

This is a very humbling and reassuring position - our work is here to benefit others, we give selflessly in what we do.  So despite mistakes we must always be willing to apologise and move on.  This is great to see from someone who runs a Sikh media channel.

Mr Kooner asked us to come and present our work regularly on Akaal Channel, which we declined.  Our films and productions reach a greater international audience online, nor are we interested in air time or fame.  But when we engage with ALL mainstream media on new releases, we will be willing to work with Akaal on promoting our work.

I now consider this matter at an end - it's good to know that there is someone who is working professionally in the Indian media world - ontrast this to Mr "I Am Sikh media" over at Sikh Channel!

*** The original post is below so you can our original issue ***

I've never been one to disregard another persons rights over their intellectual property - as a journalist I have always acknowledged that plagiarism is wrong and that citing others work always deserves a credit.

As an independent researcher and history enthusiast - I balance my work and family life with my passion for making films about British Sikh history.  I'm not paid to do this nor do I make any money from the productions I create.  Indeed, I pay more for the privilege of trying to narrate the story of my ancestors - by paying a premium for archive images, by spending my own money on travel, expenses, interviews and eventually self-publishing my work.

So ironic that in the first infringement of my intellectual property this week I happened to have been at the British Library researching regimental histories when a friend sent me the below photo:



Akaal Channel did not ask my permission to use the cover of my book - nor had they contacted my team for it or acknowledged our work.  Having been told about this infringement I called the channel head to complain - he had no idea about the misuse!  This is a terrible example of unprofessional behaviour on the part of a so called broadcaster.

The Indian channels all plead poverty to their viewers - constantly asking for donations (notice the ticker at the bottom of the screen) and asking for money to keep their free to air services going.  But what about researchers and filmmakers like me?  We do not get any support from such channels nor do we ask for money from the community at large - our efforts are not just self-funded but self-supporting.  This is why I am irate at the infringement of my hard work and effort.  

Steps will now be undertaken to ensure this does not happen - this blog post should be a warning to others that I will not tolerate anyone ripping off my work.

Further to that, I have now discovered that my work has ALSO been ripped off by a researcher in the States who has copied images from my book and ripped video from my online productions (free productions which we self-fund for others to enjoy) for his own trailer.

I am perplexed about what to do about the latter because I cannot take it seriously - it has spelling mistakes and is a shoddy piece of work.  But a copyright infringement nonetheless.  So on that note I have sent a request for the offending material to be taken down.

This blatant abuse of others hard work and efforts must end - I speak not only for myself but others I know of who have this same problem with their intellectual property rights being violated.

There are very few of us working on the British Sikh history agenda - this number will not grow (indeed it will dwindle) unless proper credit is given to those who undertake this important work at personal cost and so little gain. 

Friday, 14 February 2014

Welcome...

Welcome to our blog - we've given it a face lift as we head into a busy year of research, filmmaking and blogging.

Please do bookmark the page - you can also use the image below as a link button on your website or on social media to direct people to our main site.



* Many thanks to Jag Lall for the fantastic artwork.

Tuesday, 11 February 2014

Thanks to Leinster Regiment Association

We love hearing from fellow military and history enthusiasts - so such a surprise to receive an email from Mr David Ball, one of the founders of the Leinster Regiment Association (visit their website here).

He responded to our last message and provided some fantastic cap badges for our research.  Mr Ball also provided some interest background to the Prince of Wales's Leinster Regiment - a unit who's 2nd Battalion was formed in India.

Their website has a fantastic insight into the regimental history - which I'd suggest readers do check out.


And many thanks to David Ball!